Amazon Basics Puppy Pads vs Best Pet Supplies Pads Compared

Here is the short answer: if your puppy is going through a box of training pads every week and you keep finding wet floors around the edges, the Amazon Basics Super Absorbent Puppy Pads are almost certainly the fix. The Best Pet Supplies pads I tried were not terrible, but after four weeks of side-by-side use with Biscuit, my 10-week-old Lab mix, there was a consistent gap in leak protection that I could not ignore. The Amazon Basics pads held more, wicked faster, and locked in odor better. And they cost less per pad. That combination is hard to argue with.

I want to be fair to Best Pet Supplies here. Their pads are not garbage. They work fine for a small dog with modest output, and their edges stay taped down better than average. But Biscuit is going to be 80 pounds someday, and at 10 weeks she already goes big. When I put both brands in corners of the same room and let her use them naturally over several days, the pattern was pretty clear. The Amazon Basics pad absorbed and the Best Pet Supplies pad pooled.

	Amazon Basics Pads	Best Pet Supplies Pads
Pad Size	22 x 22 inches (regular) or 23 x 24 inches (large)	22 x 22 inches (standard only)
Layers	5-layer construction (quick-dry top, absorbent core, leak-proof bottom)	4-layer construction
Absorbent Core	Super-absorbent polymer (SAP) gel core	Cellulose fluff pulp core, no SAP gel
Leak Protection	Plastic leak-proof liner extends to pad edges	Liner stops short of edges on some pads
Odor Control	Baking soda odor absorber built into core	Light fragrance on surface only
Cost Per Pad (regular pack)	Approx. $0.31 per pad	Approx. $0.35-$0.40 per pad
Pack Sizes Available	50, 100, 150 count	50, 100 count
Adhesive Tabs	4 corner tabs standard on most packs	4 corner tabs standard
Amazon Rating	4.6 stars, 43,727 reviews	4.3 stars, fewer reviews

Where Amazon Basics Pads Win

The five-layer construction is the real difference. Most budget pads use a cellulose fluff core that absorbs fine until it saturates, at which point liquid sits on the surface or tracks sideways to the edge. Amazon Basics uses a super-absorbent polymer gel layer that locks liquid in rather than just soaking it up. With Biscuit, that meant no surface pooling even after a large go. The pad looked dry to the touch within about 30 seconds.

The leak-proof liner also matters more than most people expect. I found that with the Best Pet Supplies pads, the plastic liner on a few pads in the pack stopped just short of the edge, which meant if the puppy aimed toward a corner I got floor contact. The Amazon Basics liner runs flush to the edge and has not failed on me once across four weeks of daily use. The baking soda odor neutralizer in the core is also a real functional feature, not a marketing line. By end of day, the Amazon Basics pad smells like nothing. The Best Pet Supplies pads use a floral surface scent that fades by afternoon and then just smells like what it is.

Where Best Pet Supplies Pads Win

The Best Pet Supplies pads have one real strength: the corner tabs are aggressive. I mean that in a good way. Biscuit is in the phase where she sniffs the pad before using it, which means she gets a corner up and starts trying to shred it. The adhesive on the Best Pet Supplies pads held against this better than the Amazon Basics tabs during the first two weeks. By week three, once she was using the pad more consistently and less like a chew toy, this advantage stopped mattering. But for a puppy who is still investigating the pad with her mouth, those stronger tabs delayed a lot of cleanup.

The Best Pet Supplies pads also unroll and lay flat faster out of the bag. The Amazon Basics pads can curl at the edges for a few minutes if you just pulled them from a cold room. Not a dealbreaker, but if you are in a hurry at 6 a.m. to get the pad down before the puppy bolts off the bed, the flat-right-away factor is a small real convenience.

After four weeks with Biscuit, the pattern was consistent: the Amazon Basics pad absorbed, and the Best Pet Supplies pad pooled. That is the whole comparison, honestly.

Absorbency Under Real Conditions

I want to describe exactly how I tested this because I think it matters. I put two pads in adjacent corners of my laundry room for three days, switching positions each day so one brand was not always on the traffic side. Biscuit used both over the three days. I checked each pad immediately after use and again two hours later. The Amazon Basics pad felt dry on the surface within about 30 seconds of a large void and was fully dry at the two-hour mark. The Best Pet Supplies pad was damp on the surface after a large void and still showed a wet spot at two hours.

The polymer gel core is what creates that difference. It pulls liquid down and holds it in a gel matrix rather than leaving it in the fiber layer near the surface. If your puppy is small and goes light amounts, you probably would not notice the gap. If you have a medium or large breed puppy, or a dog who goes with volume, the SAP core is going to make a visible difference to your floors and your nose.

I also tried saturating both pads intentionally with measured water poured slowly in the center. The Amazon Basics pad absorbed 16 fluid ounces without any spread to the edges. The Best Pet Supplies pad started spreading toward the edges at about 10 fluid ounces. Neither pad failed the liner with that amount, but the Best Pet Supplies pad was clearly closer to its capacity limit. If your dog goes more than once before you replace the pad, that matters.

Odor Control: One Actually Works, One Masks

Here is where the difference is most obvious to visitors who do not know you are training a puppy. The Best Pet Supplies pads have a floral scent on the surface layer. In the first hour it mostly covers the smell. By hour three, the room smells like floral plus urine. The Amazon Basics pads use baking soda embedded in the core material. There is no masking scent. The pad just does not smell by hour three. I cannot explain the chemistry beyond what the product describes, but I can tell you my laundry room did not announce itself to guests when I was using the Amazon Basics pads.

If you change pads immediately after each use, this distinction is basically irrelevant. But most people with a puppy are not doing that. You set the pad in the morning, leave for work, and deal with it at lunch or evening. In that scenario, the difference between baking soda neutralization and floral masking is very noticeable.

Cost Breakdown

At current pricing, Amazon Basics regular pads run about 31 cents per pad in the 100-count pack. Best Pet Supplies pads run 35 to 40 cents per pad depending on the pack size you find. That is roughly a 15 to 25 percent premium for a pad that performs noticeably worse on absorbency. If you go through a pad per day, that is a small difference. If you go through three to four pads a day during active potty training, you are spending meaningfully more for worse protection.

The Amazon Basics pads also come in a 150-count pack that gets the per-pad cost down further, which the Best Pet Supplies pads do not match. For the first few months of training when you are burning through pads fast, buying in bulk and getting a better pad for less money is about as clear a decision as you will find in the pet supply aisle.

Who Should Buy Which

Buy the Amazon Basics Super Absorbent Puppy Pads if you have a medium or large breed puppy, if you want to leave a pad down for several hours without worrying about it, if odor in a shared space matters to you, or if you are buying in quantity for the next few months of training. At 4.6 stars across more than 43,000 ratings, the track record speaks for itself. The five-layer construction, SAP gel core, and edge-to-edge liner cover the scenarios where budget pads fail most often.

Consider Best Pet Supplies pads only if you have a very small breed with low output, if you replace pads multiple times a day so odor never builds, or if the stronger corner adhesive is genuinely your highest priority because your puppy is a tab-destroyer. Even then, the cost savings with Amazon Basics are real, and those corner tabs catch up after the puppy moves past the investigative chewing phase. I would try Amazon Basics first in almost every case and only switch if something about your specific dog's habits makes a different priority rank higher.